4.8/5 Based on 3500+ reviews
Free Shipping with USPS
14-Day Money-Back Guarantee
Over 20,000+ Happy Customers
Free UPS Shipping
ANNIVERSARY SALE UPDATE: Due to high demand during our 26-year anniversary sale, only a limited number of items are left. If you can still click 'Add to cart', it’s still available.
Modern refinement with character – the Martha Leather Mary Janes
The Martha Leather Mary Janes merge timeless craftsmanship with bold, contemporary design. Their split-toe profile offers a striking detail without sacrificing elegance, while the polished leather finish and slim metal-buckled strap elevate the silhouette with subtle sophistication. Built with a structured base, they’re made for women who want to make a quiet statement — with confidence and class.
Split toe design: A unique feature with modern edge – bold yet wearable and full of style
Fine craftsmanship: High-quality, handcrafted leather with a polished finish for durability and comfort
Structured construction: Flat, supportive sole for confident steps from morning to night
Minimalist strap: Sleek design with a delicate metal buckle that adds an elegant finishing touch
Individual style: For women who appreciate clean lines and standout accents
Material: Handcrafted leather with a smooth, polished surface
Sole: Flat and stable with a cushioned insole for lasting support
Design: Split toe, slim strap, and metal buckle detail
Fit: Structured and comfortable – ideal for everyday wear with a style-forward edge
Make a subtle statement with modern structure – the Martha Mary Janes are where bold design meets classic craftsmanship. Discover them now and elevate your everyday look.
We offer a 14-day return policy, so you can return your order within 14 days of receipt for a full refund.
Orders in the US include free shipping, a tracking number and are shipped out next day with USPS.
Lilly New York has over 15,000+ happy customers and our customers rate us 4.8/5.0
Anniversary Sale
From a tiny dream in 1999 to a beloved brand embraced by women across the country — what started between two best friends has grown into something bigger than we ever imagined.
26 years later, we're still creating pieces we love, and we're more grateful than ever for the community that made it all possible.
To thank you, we're celebrating with up to 80% off during our Anniversary Sale — a heartfelt gift from us to you.
*Discounts are automatically applied at checkout. You can also combine different items.
